GOOGLE GEMINI · MANUSCRIPT EVALUATION

Comprehensive Manuscript Review Prompts

Choose one of five specialist evaluations for a draft intended for a Web of Science Q1 or Q2 journal. Every prompt requests a professionally structured Microsoft Word report.

Required output Microsoft Word (.docx) report with an assessment-specific cover page
A Malaysian academic and postgraduate researchers critically reviewing a journal manuscriptCRITICAL · CONSTRUCTIVE · EVIDENCE-BASED

BEFORE YOU BEGIN

Provide the evidence required for a credible review

Upload as many of the following documents as are available. The prompt will flag missing information instead of inventing it.

Manuscript

Complete article with tables, figures and references.

Target Journal

Aims and scope, author guidelines and article type.

Supporting Evidence

Key literature, supplementary files and reporting checklist.

Review Context

Field, intended quartile and claimed contribution.

SELECT ONE ASSESSMENT

Five reviews. Five different editorial perspectives.

Select the evaluation that matches your immediate need, then copy the complete prompt into Google Gemini.

Researcher verification remains essential: Review every comment, score, citation-dependent claim and journal requirement before revising or submitting the manuscript.

Prompt copied